Elon Musk defends tweets in San Francisco securities fraud trial

Alex Spiro, legal professional for Elon Musk, heart, exits courtroom on Tuesday, January 17, 2023 in San Francisco, California, United States.

Benjamin Fanjoy | Bloomberg | Getty Photos

Tesla chairman Elon Musk appeared in federal courtroom in San Francisco on Friday to defend tweets he posted to his tens of hundreds of thousands of followers in August 2018.

The tweets mentioned he had “secured funding” to take his electrical car firm personal at $420 per share and “confirmed investor assist” for such a deal.

Tesla’s share buying and selling initially got here to a standstill after the tweets, then the shares had been extremely risky for weeks. musk mentioned later that he had held talks with the Saudi Arabian Sovereign Wealth Fund and was assured that the funding would come at his proposed worth. A deal by no means materialized.

The SEC charged Musk and Tesla with civil securities fraud following the tweets. Musk and Tesla every paid the company $20 million in fines and reached a revised settlement settlement that required Musk to briefly step down from his function as Tesla’s CEO.

His 2018 tweets additionally sparked a shareholder class motion lawsuit from Tesla traders. They claimed that Musk’s tweets misled them and mentioned that counting on his statements to make trades price them vital quantities of cash.

The shareholder trades in query occurred over a 10-day interval earlier than Musk appeared to concede {that a} take-private deal wouldn’t occur in 2018.

Musk mentioned beneath oath Friday that it was troublesome to attach Tesla’s inventory worth to his tweets.

“There have been many cases the place I believed if I tweeted one thing, the inventory worth would go down,” Musk mentioned. “For instance, I as soon as tweeted that I feel the inventory worth is simply too excessive in my view… and it is gone up, which wasn’t intuitive.”

A giant spike in buying and selling quantity after he tweeted

It is uncommon for prime executives of publicly traded corporations to talk about their inventory worth, as any remark can have an effect on worth actions.

Daniel Taylor, director of the Wharton Forensics Analytics Lab and professor on the College of Pennsylvania, analyzed each commerce in Tesla inventory that occurred on Aug. 7, 2018, the day Musk tweeted. He calculated the whole buying and selling quantity each minute from the time the market opened to the time Musk tweeted a couple of buyout.

Taylor famous that the buying and selling quantity the minute Musk tweeted at 12:48 p.m. ET that day was over $350 million, and the following minute buying and selling quantity for Tesla shares was over $250 million . Compared, the typical quantity 5 minutes earlier than Musk tweeted was $32 million per minute. Within the minute earlier than Musk tweeted, the buying and selling quantity was $24 million.

“It is typically true that correlation just isn’t causation,” Taylor informed CNBC on Friday after Musk’s first day on the witness stand. “Nevertheless, I’m not conscious of any various clarification for a 10x enhance in buying and selling quantity in the identical minute that Elon Musk tweeted.”

Musk additionally testified on Friday about his low opinion of brief sellers.

“I feel brief promoting must be made unlawful,” Musk mentioned, describing brief sellers as “unhealthy guys on Wall Avenue” who “steal” different traders. He mentioned additionally they plant tales within the media to “crash the inventory” and would “do every part of their energy to let an organization die.”

Tesla was among the many top-performing shares in August 2018 when Musk made the assertion about Tesla’s privatization. Tesla inventory worth frozen approx. 10% throughout buying and selling that day. Quick sellers face enormous losses if a specific firm’s inventory strikes increased.

A few of the plaintiffs within the ongoing lawsuit allege that Musk’s “funding secured” tweets had been aimed toward placing upward stress on Tesla inventory, leading to a so-called “brief squeeze.”

Musk’s testimony just isn’t full and the courtroom plans to listen to him once more on Monday.

WATCHES: Musk testifies about tweets

Tesla CEO Elon Musk testifies about 2018